domingo, 10 de septiembre de 2017

BioEdge: Russian babies swapped at birth

BioEdge: Russian babies swapped at birth

Saturday, September 9, 2017

Bioedge

Russian babies swapped at birth
     
Zoya's daughters Lucia (L) and Ekaterina. Picture: Zoya Tuganova
The theme of babies swapped at birth is probably more common in literature like the Gilbert and Sullivan operetta HMS Pinafore and Mark Twain’s novel The Tragedy of Pudd'nhead Wilson than it is in real life. But it happens, always raising heart-breaking issues of nature vs nurture, maternal attachment, and the need to find biological parents.

The latest tragedy, as reported in the Siberian Times, comes from the central Russian city of Chelyabinsk. In 1987 two women gave birth to daughters in a maternity ward: a Russian, Zoya Tuganova, and a Bashkir (a Turkic people) Elvira Tuligenova. The biological daughter of Zoya was fair and well-built; the biological daughter of Elvira was dark and frail. But the babies were swapped. Zoya sensed that something was amiss and screamed in protest. But the doctors insisted and she submitted.



The story unfolded like a soap opera. Zoya took home a daughter, Katya, who was raised as an Orthodox and eventually went to university. Elvira took home Luciya, who was raised as a devout Muslim. Her appearance was so different to her parents that her father was mocked as a cuckold. He got into a fight over this and ended up knifing a man to death. He went to jail and the once-prosperous family fell apart. Elvira drank herself to death. After wandering the streets with two siblings begging for food Zoya was placed in an orphanage. Now she has three children of her own and lives on welfare.

Katya was the detective who untangled this story and put Zoya in touch with her biological daughter Luciya. “Moral compensation for what happened should be paid to my mom and Luciya,” Katya told the press. “Thank God, I am fine. It should also be discussed why the children were not given decent accommodation after leaving the orphanage as foreseen by law. Beyond any doubt everyone involved in this outrageous situation should be punished.” 
Bioedge

Bioedge

Saturday, September 9, 2017

Planned Parenthood is an organisation which inspires both love and loathing. One of its admirers is the Lasker Foundation, which has just presented it with the Lasker~Bloomberg Public Service Award for services to reproductive health.

Since many Laskers have gone on to win Nobels, PP is suddenly on the starting blocks for a Nobel Peace Prize. If it were only for its success in promoting contraception and abortion, it might be too controversial even for the Norwegian Nobel Committee. However, as a one-fingered salute to President Donald Trump, who has promised to defund PP, it could prove nearly irresistible. Read all about it below. 

On a completely different topic, if you happen to live in Melbourne and are free on Thursday evening, there will be a launch of my book, The Great Human Dignity Heist, in Carlton. The details are on our Facebook page. It would be great to meet lots of BioEdge readers there.

Cheers,

 
Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
 Comment on BioedgeFind Us on FacebookFollow us on Twitter
NEWS THIS WEEK
 
by Michael Cook | Sep 09, 2017
For services to reproductive health
 
by Michael Cook | Sep 09, 2017
A British ethicist says No.
 
by Michael Cook | Sep 09, 2017
A heart-breaking story of maternal loss
 
by Michael Cook | Sep 09, 2017
What about the human dignity of prisoners?
 
by Michael Cook | Sep 09, 2017
Religion and knowledge about the technology determine what people think
 
by Xavier Symons | Sep 09, 2017
A New York Court has reaffirmed the State's ban on assisted suicide.
 
by Xavier Symons | Sep 09, 2017
A legal battle over an allegedly brain-dead American teenager is set to continue.
 
by Xavier Symons | Sep 09, 2017
Scientists are developing powerful drugs to stop ageing.
 
by Xavier Symons | Sep 09, 2017
But the fallout from the Hoffman Report continues.
BioEdge
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
BioEdge: Russian babies swapped at birth

No hay comentarios: